Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 cases solved Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Share what you know: tips, sources, questions and theories about this case. Be respectful; abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

2 discussions · 2 posts

Melissa Jordan was 26 and working as a certified nurse’s aide when she was last seen on the evening of…

SW SW

Melissa Jordan was 26 and working as a certified nurse’s aide when she was last seen on the evening of December 22, 1995, in Milan, Tennessee. She was described as a young Black female, between 5 feet 4 inches and 5 feet 6 inches tall and about 165 pounds. That night she left a residence on Robinson Street with 36-year-old Onnie B. Nesbitt intending to go out for dinner; they departed in her brownish-orange 1985 Chevrolet Celebrity or Buick Riviera and neither returned.

In early January 1996 Melissa’s vehicle was found parked at a home on Dupree Street. A search of the residence turned up drugs, money, and weapons, but no sign of Melissa. Nesbitt was missing for several weeks after December 22 before reappearing; he has been described by a judge as violent with a long criminal history and was later sentenced to 24 years on an unrelated firearms charge. It remains unclear whether he was ever publicly named a suspect in Melissa’s disappearance. The case is classified as an endangered missing person matter and remains unsolved.

Are there readers who knew Melissa, her movements in Milan in December 1995, or who remember seeing that brownish-orange 1985 Celebrity or Buick Riviera?

18 Reply Report

Melissa Ann Jordon was 26 and working as a certified nurse’s aide when she disappeared from Milan, Tennessee.

TS TS

Melissa Ann Jordon was 26 and working as a certified nurse’s aide when she disappeared from Milan, Tennessee. On December 22, 1995, she was last seen leaving the 1100 block of Robinson Street with 36-year-old Onnie B. Nesbitt; they drove off in Melissa’s brownish-orange 1985 Chevrolet Celebrity or a Buick Riviera and did not return.

In early January 1996 Melissa’s car was recovered parked at a home in the 100 block of Dupree Street. A police search of that residence turned up drugs, money, and weapons but yielded no sign of Melissa. Nesbitt was absent for several weeks after the December evening and later reappeared; he has an extensive violent criminal history and a judge noted prior assaults when sentencing him on an unrelated weapons charge. Authorities have said they suspect foul play, but Melissa’s fate remains unknown.

If anyone in Milan around December 1995 remembers Melissa, the car, or her plans that night, please share what you know.

18 Reply Report