295 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.
Forum Posts for Carmela Buchanan: Be respectful. Abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.
Does anyone else find it strange how little information there is about Carmela's life before she vanished? I've been searching for details about her background, but it's like she didn't exist outside of what Andrew mentioned. It feels like there's this huge gap in her story. Who were her friends? Did she have any hobbies or interests? It's like after her family reported her missing, everything just stopped, and any potential leads went with it. Also, has anyone looked into the club scene in New York around the time Andrew said she contacted him? Maybe someone in the music community might remember her or have details that weren't included in the initial investigation. Anyone else have thoughts on this angle? Let's keep her story alive and hope that someone out there has pieces of the puzzle we've been missing.
Send Private Message
Characters: 0/5000
Has anyone else noticed the odd timing regarding when Andrew said Carmela called him? He stated she called three years before her sister reported her missing in 2001, which would have been around 1998. That seems pretty strange to me because if she really did call him, why didn't he inform her family earlier? Also, wouldn't she have been in touch with at least one of them if she was really in New York? The whole thing could have been cleared up if she was alive and well. I'm not saying Andrew had anything to do with her disappearance, but it's just peculiar that he was the only one saying she'd contacted anyone. Also, remembering someone calling you, three years after the fact down to almost the exact year, when there's no other evidence of it happening, feels off, don’t you think?
