Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
298 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Forum Posts for Elliott Speer:
Be respectful. Abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

I’ve been thinking about the Speer case, and something that really caught my attention is the role of the students during this difficult time. It must’ve been incredibly challenging for them to process such a shocking event on their own campus. From what I’ve read, Reverend Speer was quite well-liked and had a strong rapport with the students, which must have made his murder even more upsetting for them.
I wonder how the atmosphere at Mount Hermon changed in the aftermath of the incident. Were there any significant shifts in student morale or behavior? How did the school support the students through their grief and fear? It’s hard to imagine being a young person dealing with the loss of a respected figure in such a violent way. If anyone has any insights or can point me toward sources about the students’ perspectives during that time, I’d really appreciate it.
My thoughts go out to the family and everyone affected by this unspeakable act. Even though so much time has passed, it's clear that it continues to impact many.
I recently came across the case of Reverend Elliott Speer and one aspect of it that keeps haunting me is the role of Reverend Speer's controversial liberal philosophies at the school. From what I've gathered, there was quite a bit of tension leading up to his tragic death. It's well-documented that his progressive ideas clashed with the more conservative views of William R. Moody, leading to Moody's resignation.
This got me thinking about whether Speer's philosophies might have played a role in creating a larger pool of potential suspects or motives. Was there anyone particularly aggrieved or threatened by the changes he was introducing at Mount Hermon? I can't help but wonder if the educational reforms he was advocating became a focal point of resentment that tragically spilled over into violence. If anyone has more details about how these differences were perceived by the broader community or among his colleagues, I'd love to hear your thoughts. It's so deeply upsetting to think that a dedicated educator could have been targeted for simply trying to progress the curriculum for the benefit of the students.
My heart goes out to his family and those who were close to him, having to endure such a senseless loss. Let's hope one day, for their sake, answers are found.
I've been diving into the Speer murder case and can't get over the strange circumstances surrounding Thomas E. Elder Sr. and his role at Mount Hermon. It's one thing for Burnham Carter to pin so much on him in "The Devil’s Chapel," but what's really bugging me is the speech impediment. Students loved Elder for it—some called it endearing—but at the same time, isn't it odd that his voice drew so much attention yet didn’t lead to more solid leads? You’d think someone would have heard something if Elder was involved in some way that night.
It's maddening how a single characteristic can make someone so memorable yet still leave us with more questions than answers. I've read that there were vague reports of voices heard around the time Speer was shot, but none ever definitively matched Elder’s distinct voice. It feels like a cryptic piece of a puzzle that never gets solved. Hope Speer's family finds peace someday, though I'm sure it lingers in their minds. These cold cases leave such a haunting legacy. What are your thoughts on how speech or sound could influence a case like this?