Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
298 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Forum Posts for James Butler:
Be respectful. Abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

I’ve been thinking about the atmosphere in Nuttal & Mann's Saloon on that fateful August day. It’s chilling to imagine the tension that must have been in the air as Hickok took that seat with his back to the door, something he was reportedly uncomfortable with. For someone like Wild Bill, who was known for being so vigilant and aware of his surroundings, it just goes to show how even experienced individuals can find themselves in vulnerable positions. It's a stark reminder of how quickly life can change. My heart goes out to those who witnessed it and to Hickok’s friends and family who had to deal with such a sudden and grievous loss. Does anyone know if sitting with one’s back to the wall was a common practice for others in similar professions during that time period, or was it more unique to Hickok?
I’ve been reading a lot about the circumstances around Wild Bill Hickok's murder, and one thing that's been gnawing at me is the "dead man's hand" that he was reportedly holding when Jack McCall shot him. Imagine the chaos and panic in Nuttal & Mann's Saloon when the shot rang out, and there’s Hickok, one of the West's most legendary figures, sitting there, lifeless, his cards still clutched in his hand. It’s eerie how such a tragic moment could go on to be immortalized in poker lore. I can’t help but feel for the folks who witnessed that scene and had to live with those haunting memories. Hickok was apparently just trying to enjoy a straightforward poker game, like he must have done countless times before. It makes you wonder about the unpredictability of life and how suddenly things can change. Thoughts?
Hey everyone,

I recently came across a fascinating aspect of the Wild Bill Hickok case that I hadn’t really thought about before. With all the stories centered around the notorious “dead man’s hand,” I'm struck by the idea that Hickok's usual precautions just couldn’t protect him that tragic day. It makes me think about the vulnerability we all face despite our best efforts.

We all know Wild Bill was famous for his cautious nature, often choosing to sit with his back against a wall to keep an eye on his surroundings. The turn of events at Nuttal & Mann’s Saloon, where he compromised on his preference, is such a haunting reminder of how sometimes circumstances just don’t allow us to stick to our instincts, no matter how seasoned or aware we are.
I can’t help but wonder if things would have turned out differently if he’d managed to get his usual seat or if Nuttal & Mann's had been quieter that day. It adds such a layer of what-ifs and underscores how fleeting safety can be, even for someone as sharp and experienced as Hickok.
Sending thoughts to the family and friends of everyone involved, as it must have been a time of immense sorrow and confusion. The ripples of that moment in history really stay with you.
Would love to hear your thoughts or if anyone’s come across similar scenarios in other cases?