Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
298 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Forum Posts for April Pennington:
Be respectful. Abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

Hey everyone, I've been following April's case for quite some time, and something that really baffles me is the involvement, or rather, the lack of any solid account of what happened with Patrick J. "P.J." Allain that night. It's super troubling how he initially claimed they all just hung out in the woods but then later changed his story to say they raped April and that Leniart had plans to murder her. It makes me wonder about his true motives and reasons for changing this narrative. Was he lying to reduce his own sentence or was there something more sinister at play?
It’s so odd that despite Allain's confession to raping April, he couldn’t be prosecuted because the statute of limitations had passed. How does a system allow that? It makes me think about how justice is served in seemingly cut-and-dry cases. Also, considering his involvement, why did it take so long for all this to unravel?
Really curious what everyone else thinks about Allain's changing stories. Did he genuinely fear Leniart, or was there something more to his hesitance to come forward with the full truth from the start? Such a frustrating and perplexing aspect of this case! Let's hope with the retrial, more light will be shed on what truly happened that night.
I’ve always found it really odd that James Butler allegedly saw April in Virginia Beach three years after her disappearance. It's intriguing that she was with a toddler and seemed to be in a rough state. The fact that she introduced herself is chilling if true, but can we trust his account given his traumatic brain injury? Memory can be so unreliable, especially in cases like these. It’s a shame this potential sighting couldn’t be investigated further considering the condition he was in. Anyone else think there might have been more to this sighting or was it just a case of mistaken identity? Also, was there any insight into who that late-twenties man could've been? The thought of her potentially being alive but in distress all those years is haunting.
I've been following April's case closely, and something that's always puzzled me is the phone calls from Leniart to her house on the day of her disappearance. I mean, five calls in one day? There had to be a reason why he was so insistent on contacting her. Did April get the chance to answer any of those calls, or were they just missed? It seems too coincidental given everything that happened later on. Also, if he denied knowing her, what was his explanation for calling her house those times? Anyone else here have thoughts on this aspect or know if it ever came up during the trial?