Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
298 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Forum Posts for Anthony Scott Smalls:
Be respectful. Abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

Hey everyone,
I've been reading through the details of the tragic incident involving Anthony "Scotty" Smalls, and something that hasn't been discussed enough is the bewildering choice of charges against Darrin Ray Carter: second-degree manslaughter. I mean, Carter apparently shot Anthony at close range without a preceding argument. How does that not elevate to a higher charge? These legal distinctions are so frustrating to understand, especially when a life is lost under such horrific circumstances.
My heart goes out to his friends and family. It must be utterly devastating for them to see the person responsible facing seemingly less severe charges. If there's anyone who can explain the legal rationale behind charging decisions in a case like this, I'd appreciate it. Is it due to the absence of intent, or does Kentucky law have specific guidelines that dictate this kind of charge? Clearly, there's so much more to this case than meets the eye.
Thinking of you, Scotty's loved ones. Stay strong.
I've been following the tragic case of Anthony Scott "Scotty" Smalls, and it's just devastating what happened to him. One thing that keeps coming up for me is the question of why Scotty was visiting that residence in the first place. From what I gather, he didn't have any known connections to Darrin Ray Carter before that night.
I'm curious if anyone has more information about their relationship, if any? It's hard to make sense of how someone could open the door and then shoot a man seemingly without provocation. It’s chilling to think there was no apparent altercation before the shooting.
My heart goes out to Scotty’s family and friends. It's distressing to think about the void left by his absence and the questions they must have. I hope they find some peace in the face of this senseless act. If anyone has updates on the investigation or more insights into why these two men crossed paths, please share. We shouldn't let this story fade away.
I've been following this case closely, and something about the events leading up to Scotty's tragic death has been puzzling me. From everything we've heard, it seems there was no apparent argument between him and Darrin Carter before the shooting occurred. This just breaks me. How can someone just open the door and shoot without even a heated exchange? It makes me wonder if Scotty even knew what was happening in those final moments.
The fact that Darrin Carter tried to hide the gun afterward suggests to me that he knew what he did was wrong, but it still doesn't seem to answer the biggest question—why? My heart goes out to Scotty's family as they navigate through this nightmare, trying to comprehend how someone they knew could do something so senseless. I hope authorities can piece together more information to help give Scotty's loved ones some answers, or at least some semblance of peace.