Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
295 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Forum Posts for Arthur Fleece Crenshaw:
Be respectful. Abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

I've been reading about the tragic end of Deputy Arthur Fleece Crenshaw and Federal Agent John Waters, and it really makes you think about the immense risks that officers took during the Prohibition era. It's awful to imagine a close-knit community like Dade City being shaken by such violence. One aspect that struck me was the courage it must have taken for Crenshaw and Waters to approach the Sturkie stock farm that day, knowing full well the dangers involved.
It's a sobering reminder of how volatile the situation was. These officers were just trying to uphold the law, yet they faced an organized and lethal resistance. I can't help but feel for the families left behind, who not only lost loved ones but had to endure the fact that justice was never truly served with all suspects ultimately walking free. It's chilling to think how their deaths underscored the dire threats law enforcement faced regularly back then. I just hope that, in time, their bravery is remembered more prominently, and their sacrifices acknowledged beyond the cold lines of a history book.
Did any of you come across the bit about how Paul Overstreet discovered the crime scene? It's mentioned that he found Arthur Fleece Crenshaw and John Waters still in the car, which was somehow still in gear. I can't begin to imagine the shock and horror he must have felt at that moment. As a member of the community, stumbling onto something so gruesome must have been incredibly traumatic. Besides the immediate grief for the families of Crenshaw and Waters, I wonder how much this tragic discovery affected Overstreet and others in the area. It must not have been easy to shake something like that off, you know? Just another layer of sadness to an already tragic event. Thoughts?
Has anyone else looked into Paul Overstreet's involvement in the discovery of the bodies? It's intriguing how he was the one to find them, but I read somewhere that living on the stock farm might put him closer to any moonshining activities—either knowingly or unknowingly. I imagine he was terrified stumbling upon such a horrific scene, but it does make me wonder if he could have any insights or details that might not have been fully explored during the initial investigation. It's such a tough situation, especially given how close-knit communities like Dade City were back then. The fact that this happened so close to his home is chilling. Does anyone have more information on what became of him after the fact or if he remained involved in any way as the case unfolded?