Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
298 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Forum Posts for James Edward Smillie:
Be respectful. Abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

I’ve been following the James Smillie case, and I can't stop thinking about the emotional toll this must have taken on his family. Domestic disputes are always complicated, and while the outcome is clear from a legal standpoint, it doesn’t lessen the impact on those who knew and loved him. I'm curious about the communication between Sgt. Laden and Smillie before the tragic end. Apparently, they had been talking on the phone. I wonder if there were signs or cues that could have indicated this would escalate. It’s just an incredibly difficult situation for everyone involved. Sending thoughts to the family and hoping they find some peace in the midst of their loss.
Hey everyone,
I've been diving into the James Edward Smillie case, and something that's been on my mind is the way law enforcement handles domestic disturbance calls. It's such a difficult situation for everyone involved, not just the officers but also the family members who often have to make heart-wrenching decisions. In this case, two family members managed to escape unharmed, but I can only imagine the fear and anxiety they felt while waiting outside, not knowing what was happening inside their own home.
The fact that Sgt. Laden tried to de-escalate the situation over the phone shows how much departments emphasize peaceful resolutions, but it seems like sometimes these situations are just unpredictable. I wish there were more resources or training for officers to handle these types of calls without them ending like they did for James.
It's so important for us to remember the human element here—Smillie was someone's family, friend, maybe even a neighbor, and now lives are changed forever. Anyone else have thoughts on how these situations could be handled differently to better protect everyone involved?
Sending thoughts to anyone affected by this, and hoping for a future where incidents like this become fewer and farther between.
Stay safe,
[username]
I came across this case recently and it's been weighing on my mind, especially when thinking about the family members who got out safely. It must have been incredibly distressing for them to witness such a situation unfold with James Edward Smillie, someone they knew and loved. I can’t imagine the emotions they must have felt, both during and after the incident. Domestic disturbances are already stressful, and adding this outcome makes it even more devastating.
It’s also interesting how the officers had to make split-second decisions under pressure. Sgt. Laden was able to initially calm Smillie down, even getting him to drop the rifle. It’s unfortunate things escalated from there. I keep wondering if there could have been a different outcome if the situation had somehow stayed at the negotiation phase. I hope the family can find some peace as they process everything. Does anyone know if there have been any support groups or anything put in place for family members in circumstances like this?