In the late summer of 2020, a 33-year-old man named Frederick Edward Mitchell vanished from Edmond, Oklahoma, leaving behind a community and a web of unsettling questions. He was last seen on September 5, 2020, in the company of another man, Phillip Smith. At the time of his disappearance, Mitchell was described as being 5'10' and weighing around 150 pounds, with blond hair, blue eyes, and a short beard.
He was also known to wear eyeglasses and had a distinctive tattoo on the right side of his chest. The initial days following their disappearance offered a grim clue when Phillip Smith's car was discovered abandoned on September 7th, its hood left up, suggesting a possible vehicle breakdown that was far from ordinary. This discovery was the first indication that their disappearance was not voluntary and that they had likely met with foul play.
The investigation into the disappearance of Frederick Mitchell and Phillip Smith soon took a dark turn, pointing toward a sinister plot believed to have been orchestrated from behind prison walls. Authorities began to suspect that both men were victims of a murder-for-hire scheme ordered by Phillip Smith's own brother, Mikell 'Bulldog' Smith, a man already serving time for three separate murder convictions. Informants revealed a chilling motive, suggesting that Mikell was enraged that his brother, Phillip, had been bringing unhoused individuals to their mother's home. His reported fear was that this would expose their mother to COVID-19, a fear that allegedly culminated in him putting a hit on his own brother and his associate, Frederick Mitchell. This theory directed investigators toward a specific location, a two-and-a-half-acre compound in Logan County ominously known as the 'bully farm'.
The 'bully farm' has been linked by authorities to several other missing persons cases, painting a picture of a place with a violent and disturbing history. According to information provided to law enforcement, it is believed that Mitchell and Smith were lured to a party at the compound on the night they went missing and were killed there. While no charges have been filed specifically in connection with their disappearances, the ongoing investigation has led to the discovery of human remains. Investigators have found bone fragments at three separate locations: the 'bully farm' itself, a nearby site half a mile away, and an oil field lease road in a different town. The Logan County Sheriff's Office is handling the complex investigation, which now involves attempting to identify these remains. The case of Frederick Mitchell is a harrowing story that began with two men disappearing and has since unraveled to include allegations of a contract killing ordered from prison, a property connected to multiple disappearances, and the grim discovery of unidentified human remains.Last Seen: Sep 5, 2020
