Account
Jan 24, 2026
Jan 24, 2026
Madeline
Benitez
64
64
5'4 - 5'6 inches
200 lbs
White
Female
Benitez was last seen in Santa Cruz, California on October 29, 2011. She has never been heard from again. She was reported missing on November 8, nine days after the last time she showed up for work. She worked at a Burger King restaurant in Capitola, California once a week, and attended church every Sunday. When a friend checked Benitez's apartment in the 1600 block of Soquel Avenue, nothing was out of place or missing. Benitez marked off each day on her calendar; the last mark had been on October 29, the day she was last seen by coworkers. Authorities believe she may be with a local homeless man known only as Randy; he often stays in Capitola. He's described as White, about 5'8 with a slender build and a brown and gray beard. He was in his fifties in 2011. The circumstances of Benitez's disappearance are unclear. She is originally from New York City. Her case remains unsolved.
Oct 29, 2011
Santa Cruz
California
Santa Cruz
9
Santa Cruz Police Departmen
831-420-5870
01/25/2026
