Jennifer Poole Missing Person Case

Jun 12, 2010

Dec 21, 2020

Jennifer

Poole

54

38

64 inches

68 inches

130 lbs

150 lbs

White / Caucasian

Female

On a spring day in 2010, 38-year-old Jennifer Lee Poole, known to her loved ones as Jenny, vanished from her life in Bay Shore, New York. She was last seen on the afternoon of April 29, 2010, at her apartment on Mowbray Avenue. At the time of her disappearance, Jennifer was a woman with distinctive features, including multiple piercings up her ears, a scar across her collarbone, and several tattoos: two dog paw prints with the name "JOEY" on her neck, a rose with the name "Michael" on her back, and a small, green, home-done lightning bolt tattoo, also on her back. When she disappeared, her purse and wallet were gone, but her bank account was never touched, and her cell phone fell silent, never to be used again. The circumstances surrounding Jennifer's disappearance quickly became alarming to her family. When her apartment was checked, it was found in disarray, with her belongings appearing to have been searched through. The scene within the apartment suggested a violent struggle had taken place. A piece of carpet had been cut out and was missing from the floor. Even more ominously, investigators discovered two pools of blood, each described as being about the size of a tennis ball, that had soaked through to the floorboards beneath where the carpet once lay. This discovery turned a missing person case into one with deeply troubling implications. Jennifer's family, particularly her sister, has been relentless in their search for answers. Her sister has expressed her belief that Jennifer was murdered and her body was disposed of near the waterfront, which was close to her apartment. She also raised concerns about Jennifer's landlord, stating he had given conflicting accounts of the day Jennifer was last seen. Shortly before she went missing, a family member reportedly saw Jennifer with two black eyes, which she explained away as an accident from a picture falling off the wall. The combination of her unexplained disappearance, the evidence found in her ransacked apartment, and the suspicious details leading up to the day she was last seen paints a grim picture. Despite the passage of years, Jennifer Poole's case remains unsolved, leaving her family with unanswered questions about what happened to her after she was last seen in her Bay Shore apartment.

Apr 29, 2010

Bay Shore

New York

Suffolk County

11706

21127

Suffolk County Police Department

Yaphank

New York

Suffolk County

11980

30 Yaphank Ave, New York

6318526110

Local

Law Enforcement

CC#10-225085

2010-05-07

Suffolk County Police Department

Brown

Brown

Brown

09/08/2026