Account
Sep 23, 2011
Jan 12, 2024
Shelly
Turner
56
38
65 inches
170 lbs
White / Caucasian
Female
On a late September evening in 2006, 38-year-old Shelly Sue Turner was last seen in Dayton, Ohio. A mother of two, Shelly was at a local bar, Slugs Tavern on Smithville Road, with her fiancé, Harold Baker. Reports from that night suggest a possible confrontation occurred between her fiancé and an ex-boyfriend at the tavern. After this point, Shelly's life seems to vanish into a series of conflicting stories and unanswered questions. She was never heard from again, leaving behind her two sons, one of whom was just an infant, and all of her personal belongings, including her Ford Explorer and her last paycheck. The only item that seemingly disappeared with her was her debit card, which showed no activity after she went missing. At the time of her disappearance, Shelly was described as a white female with long, straight blonde hair with bangs and blue eyes. She was approximately 5'5" tall and weighed 170 pounds, and had a scar on her lower abdomen from a Cesarean section. She wore either contact lenses or plastic-framed eyeglasses and was last seen wearing blue jeans. The initial investigation into Shelly's disappearance was complicated by the account given by her fiancé, Harold Baker. He claimed that as they were leaving the tavern, Shelly saw a man named "Bill" in a gray Pontiac Grand Am, called out to him, and after a brief conversation, she gave her engagement ring back to Baker and left with the other man. This version of events, however, was met with skepticism by those who knew Shelly. Her family and friends described her as a devoted mother who would not have willingly abandoned her children. She had recently purchased pumpkins to carve for Halloween with her children, an act that spoke to her commitment to her family life. Furthermore, a coworker revealed that Shelly had expressed a desire to end her relationship with Baker, a detail that stood in stark contrast to the happy image Baker portrayed of their engagement. As days turned into weeks with no word from Shelly, the concern of her loved ones grew, and the Dayton Police Department intensified their search efforts, believing that foul play was involved. Years would pass without any resolution in Shelly's case, leaving her family in a painful state of limbo. The breakthrough finally came when investigators arrested Harold Baker and charged him with her murder, felonious assault, and tampering with evidence. Despite his insistence of innocence, Baker was ultimately convicted of murdering Shelly. The conviction brought a measure of legal justice, but it did not bring Shelly home. Her body has never been found, a source of ongoing anguish for her family. The case of Shelly Sue Turner is a tragic story of a life cut short and a family left to grapple with an immeasurable loss. While the legal system held her killer accountable, the absence of her remains leaves an open wound for those who continue to hope for her return. The overview of the case reflects a loving mother whose sudden disappearance unraveled a dark reality, culminating in a murder conviction but no final closure for her loved ones.
Sep 30, 2006
Dayton
Ohio
Montgomery County
21726
Dayton Police Department
Dayton
Ohio
,
OCA# 5783721
2006-10-09
Dayton Police Department
Blond/Strawberry
Blue
Blue
05/27/2026
