Account
Oct 12, 2017
May 13, 2018
Timothy
Smith
64
25
73 inches
250 lbs
White / Caucasian
Male
In the spring of 1985, a young man named Timothy Howard Smith, just 25 years old, found his life in peril in the small city of Duncan, Oklahoma. Originally from Tennessee, Timothy, also known as Otis, had been drawn to Oklahoma by the prospect of work in the booming oil industry. However, the promise of a new beginning had soured. On April 15, 1985, Timothy made a frantic phone call to his mother in Tennessee. He was scared, telling her that someone was after him and that he desperately needed money for a bus ticket to come home. This phone call would be the last time his family ever heard from him. He never made it back to Tennessee, and the life of this young man became a decades-long mystery. The days following Timothy's disappearance only deepened the concern for his well-being. A white 1965 Ford Galaxy he was known to drive was spotted being operated by another individual in Duncan. The license plate on the vehicle had been changed. When questioned, the woman driving the car claimed that Timothy had bought it from her but had not completed the payments, so she had taken it back. The car, which Timothy had reportedly purchased for only $100 and was in poor condition, was later impounded on March 24, 1985. Tragically, the vehicle was not thoroughly searched until months later, after it had already been sold to a salvage yard for scrap. The delay in reporting him missing, which wasn't until October 30, 1985, further complicated the initial stages of the investigation. Authorities strongly suspect that Timothy met with foul play, and his case is now considered an unsolved homicide. The investigation suggests that his disappearance may be linked to drug activity. The circumstances surrounding his last known days paint a grim picture of a young man who feared for his life and was trying to escape a dangerous situation. The belief among investigators is that Timothy may have been killed in Duncan and his body subsequently hidden, a theory that has haunted his family and the community for years. Despite the passage of time, the Duncan Police Department continues to seek answers, keeping the case open and following up on any new leads that emerge in the hope of one day bringing closure to the family of Timothy Howard Smith. The overview of this case reveals a tragic story of a young man who moved to a new state for a better life, only to have it cut short under terrifying and mysterious circumstances that remain unresolved.
Apr 15, 1985
Duncan
Oklahoma
Stephens County
73533
34125
Duncan Police Department
Duncan
Oklahoma
Stephens County
73533
Dustin Smith
Investigator
18 South 7th Street, Oklahoma
5802552112
Local
Law Enforcement
85-M-40
1985-10-30
Duncan Police Department
Brown
Brown
Brown
06/07/2026
