Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 cases solved Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.
SENTENCED

Sorber-Petrie sentenced in KayLee Dutton murder case

Matthew Sorber-Petrie received consecutive prison terms Nov. 10 after a jury convicted him of murder, multiple firearm counts and obstruction in the Jan. 17, 2025 killing.

KayLee Dutton, Cedar City, Utah
Background photo: DXR / CC BY-SA 4.0 (Wikimedia Commons)

What happened

Matthew Sorber-Petrie (24) was sentenced Nov. 10, 2026, by 5th District Judge Meb Anderson after a jury convicted him in August 2026 of murder, five counts of felony discharge of a firearm causing bodily injury and obstruction of justice. The judge ordered all sentences to run consecutively.

Sorber-Petrie received 15 years to life on the murder conviction and five separate five-years-to-life terms for the firearm counts. The judge also imposed one to 15 years for obstruction of justice and shorter terms for two misdemeanor drug convictions; the court ordered the prison terms served one after another. The judge additionally ordered fines of $60,000 and $24,093.19 in restitution, with responsibility for restitution shared among the co-defendants.

Prosecutors said Sorber-Petrie supplied the rifle used in the fatal shooting and helped create and amplify the false belief among his roommates that they were being stalked, which set the confrontation and chase in motion. Sorber-Petrie remained at home during the shooting; two roommates pursued KayLee Dutton’s truck and opened fire. Several family members and the surviving passenger addressed the court at sentencing.

Case background

On Jan. 17, 2025, 17-year-old KayLee Joan Dutton was shot and killed while driving her red pickup northwest of Cedar City. Her best friend, Sydney Neal, who was riding in the truck, survived with injuries. Investigators said the truck was pursued for several miles by a dark pickup before the shooting.

Police quickly located the suspect vehicle and arrested four roommates from a Cedar City townhome. Authorities determined the teenagers had been driving through the neighborhood for reasons unrelated to the suspects; the men had become convinced they were being stalked.

Two of the men who followed the truck, Ethan Galloway and Michael Hess-Witucki, pleaded guilty to murder and related firearm charges and were sentenced in September 2025. A third man, Aldric Felipe, pleaded guilty to obstruction and a restricted-person firearm charge and received a suspended prison sentence and probation. Sorber-Petrie was tried as the final defendant; jurors convicted him in August 2026.

Timeline

  • January 17, 2025KayLee Dutton, 17, was shot and killed while driving near Cedar City; her friend Sydney Neal survived.
  • January 18-21, 2025Suspect vehicle located; four roommates arrested and formally charged in connection with the shooting.
  • September 2025Ethan Galloway and Michael Hess-Witucki pleaded guilty to murder and received prison terms; Aldric Felipe pleaded guilty to obstruction and restricted-person firearm possession and received probation.
  • August 20, 2026A jury convicted Matthew Sorber-Petrie of murder, five counts of felony discharge of a firearm causing bodily injury, and obstruction of justice.
  • November 10, 2026Judge Meb Anderson sentenced Matthew Sorber-Petrie to consecutive prison terms totaling multiple 15-years-to-life sentences and additional terms and fines.

Read the full case file for KayLee Dutton, with case details, photos and the community discussion.

Sources

This article is based on published news reports and official statements, together with our case records. People who are charged with a crime are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court. Read our editorial standards. See an error? Let us know and we'll correct it.

More case breakthroughs