Do you know who murdered Bonnie Daye? In his South Durham, North Carolina, neighborhood, Bonnie Lee Daye was known as a grandfather figure to many. At 81 years old, the Black / African American man was generous with his time and his car, often driving neighbors to work or helping them out in any way he could. He was a good man, a fixture on his street, and his sudden and violent death left his community heartbroken and searching for answers.
The morning of Wednesday, June 15, 2005, felt wrong to his neighbors on Buxton Drive. Flora Scott, who lived nearby, noticed that Mr. Daye’s cream-colored 2002 Cadillac Seville wasn't in its usual spot when she woke up at 6 a.m. Throughout the day, she and other friends grew more concerned when no one could find him. He had last been seen alive around 10:30 p.m. the previous evening, Tuesday, June 14. The terrible truth was discovered at 7:31 p.m. when Durham police officers were called to his home at 409 Buxton Drive. His grandchildren had found him.
Their screams brought Ms. Scott running over, where she saw a horrific scene inside the front bedroom.
Mr. Daye’s body was on the floor at the foot of his bed, wrapped tightly in a blanket or bedspread, with the ends tied. An autopsy would later confirm that he had been strangled to death with a belt. Investigators from the Durham Police Department found no signs of forced entry into the home, and aside from his missing car, nothing of significance appeared to have been stolen. The motive for the brutal killing of a beloved elderly man in his own home remained a mystery.
The investigation quickly located Mr. Daye's missing Cadillac. Around 9:30 p.m. that same night, the car was found abandoned about a mile away in the 500 block of Atlantic Street, near Mutual Drive. Police processed the vehicle for evidence and followed up on numerous leads over the years, but the case grew cold. No arrests were ever made, and no suspects have ever been publicly named in connection with the homicide.
Years after the murder, the Durham Police Department continued to seek the public’s help in solving the case. In 2016 and again in February 2020, on the 15th anniversary of the crime, investigators asked for anyone with information to come forward. Homicide investigator David Cramer emphasized that even the smallest detail could be the key to breaking the case open. "Anybody that was acquainted with Mr. Daye around the time of the homicide, anyone that knew him or had personal knowledge of his activities, anything like that that might be beneficial to solving this," Cramer said. "We ask, as small as it may be, to reach out and let us know."
The shock and grief in the community were palpable. "I can't believe anyone would hurt a man like that," one neighbor said in the days after the killing. Flora Scott, who had known him well, expressed the collective disbelief: "I still don’t know what to think. It’s a shock; he was a good man." For Mr. Daye's family and friends, the lack of answers has meant years of unresolved pain.
As of February 2020, the murder of Bonnie Daye remains an active cold case with the Durham Police Department. Investigators are still hoping for that one crucial piece of information that will bring a killer to justice and provide long-awaited closure for his loved ones. Durham CrimeStoppers is offering a reward for information that leads to an arrest. Anyone with information is urged to call Durham CrimeStoppers at 919-683-1200 or the Durham Police Department at 919-560-4440.