A college student is found dead in an apartment breezeway Dennis Stuart Hayle was a young man with a future so bright it seemed all but guaranteed. At 22 years old, the Hempstead, New York native was a popular senior at North Carolina A&T State University in Greensboro, poised to graduate in the spring of 2009 with a double major in criminal justice and political science. A member of the Omega Psi Phi fraternity, Dennis, a Black man, was known for his leadership, serving as Vice Basileus of his chapter and Sergeant at Arms of the National Pan Hellenic Council. He had aspirations of becoming a lawyer or a lobbyist, dreams that felt tangible and within reach. Just a week before his death, he had traveled to Washington, D.C., for President Barack Obama's inauguration, an event his family said he found incredible and inspiring.
Those who knew Dennis remember a person of many talents and deep character. At Uniondale High School on Long Island, he was a multi-sport athlete, playing football, lacrosse, and wrestling.
He served his community as an acolyte at the Church of the Transfiguration in Freeport. In Greensboro, he volunteered as a mentor and served breakfast at the Greensboro Urban Ministry soup kitchen. His fraternity brother, Uche Byrd, recalled Dennis’s natural talent for drawing, noting that he had recreated the fraternity’s shield. “He didn’t get into it with nobody. I’m so shocked. I don’t know what happened,” Byrd said after the tragedy. “He had such a bright future… The statistics for minority men aren’t good, but he was beating them.”
The future his friends and family saw for him was stolen in the pre-dawn hours of Sunday, January 25, 2009. At approximately 3:35 a.m., officers with the Greensboro Police Department responded to a call about a shooting at the Campus Courtyard Two Apartments at 805 Homeland Avenue, an off-campus complex where Dennis lived. When they arrived, they found Dennis lying unresponsive in the building’s outdoor breezeway. Paramedics pronounced him dead at the scene. The concrete corridor was stained with blood where his life had ended.
An autopsy later confirmed that Dennis Hayle died from a single gunshot wound. The sound of the fatal shot had been heard by some neighbors, but in a complex that had seen another shooting just the weekend prior, it was tragically dismissed. “We heard the gunshots,” one neighbor and fellow student told a reporter. “We didn’t think nothing about it because it happens all the time.” Dennis’s murder was the third homicide in the city of Greensboro in as many days, a fact that shook the community and the university.
The Greensboro Police Department immediately launched an investigation. In the days that followed, officers canvassed the area, knocking on every door within a half-mile radius, desperate for leads. They spoke with hundreds of people, but a motive for the shooting remained elusive. No suspects were ever publicly named, and no arrests have ever been made. The case, filled with questions and a profound sense of loss, eventually went cold.
In the wake of the murder, the North Carolina A&T campus was engulfed in grief. The university’s chancellor, Stanley Battle, issued a statement saying, “The university is heartbroken as the result of what occurred with Dennis Hayle.” The school provided grief counseling for students and held a vigil to honor his memory. For his family, the pain has been unending, compounded by the lack of answers. "My outcome doesn't change," his mother, Stephanie Hayle, said through tears months after his death. "But I would like to know why. For myself and my daughter and the rest of my family... Dennis didn't deserve this."
As of January 2024, more than fifteen years after his death, Dennis Hayle’s case remains an unsolved homicide, one of more than 170 cold cases in the city of Greensboro. Investigators believe that someone has information that could finally bring justice to Dennis and his family. "There is always somebody out there that does know something," Greensboro Police Sgt. J.R. Waddell said in 2024, expressing hope that a witness's conscience might lead them to come forward.
A combined reward is available for information in the case. The North Carolina Governor’s Office is offering a reward of $5,000, and the Greensboro/Guilford Crime Stoppers is offering an additional reward of up to $5,000. The total reward is up to $10,000 for information that leads to the arrest and conviction of the person or persons responsible for the murder of Dennis Hayle. Anyone with information is urged to call the Greensboro/Guilford Crime Stoppers at 336-373-1000.