Raiford Matthews Jr., a 34-year-old Black man known to some as "Sincere" or "Kane," is remembered by loved ones as a funny, smart, and determined person. His sister recalled that he had a difficult childhood but was a loving brother who wanted to strive to become a better person. Formerly of Ayden, North Carolina, he was a high school graduate who had worked various jobs, including as a cashier. He was a father, and his daughter later wrote, "My Daddy i love you like no other."
On the afternoon of Monday, December 7, 2015, that life was cut short in a burst of gunfire. Just after 12:15 p.m., police were dispatched to the University Market and Gazelle gas station in the 1100 block of West Chapel Hill Street in Durham. The area, just a few blocks from Duke University's campus, was busy with midday activity. The owner of the convenience store, Ali Alsaras, told reporters he heard five shots from the side parking lot.
He then saw a man stumble into the front lot and collapse.
When officers arrived, they found Raiford Matthews Jr. lying in the parking lot with gunshot wounds. He was pronounced dead at the scene. Witnesses described a chaotic scene, with people running and ducking for cover when the shots were fired. A man who worked nearby said, "Everybody started running." Neither the store owner nor any of the customers inside the market were injured in the shooting.
The Durham Police Department immediately began an investigation into the city's latest homicide. The proximity of the shooting to Duke University and Immaculata Catholic School prompted lockdowns and alerts to students and staff as a precaution while police searched for a possible gunman. Investigators canvassed the area for evidence and witnesses, but no immediate arrests were made and few details about a potential suspect or motive were released to the public.
In the days following the killing, Raiford’s family announced a memorial service to be held in Ayden. His mother, Carol Judawn Gooding Underwood, survived him. On a memorial website, friends and family shared memories, describing him as strong-willed and giving. One person wrote, "God took something from us and justice will be serve one day." Another simply said, "Love you brother. Always."
Years have passed since Raiford Matthews was killed, and his case has grown cold. No charges have ever been filed, and the investigation remains open with the Durham Police Department. His death was one of several dozen homicides in Durham in 2015, a year marked by a significant level of gun violence in the city. The case is now listed among Durham's cold cases, a reminder of a life taken and a family still waiting for answers.
The investigation into the murder of Raiford Matthews Jr. is ongoing. Authorities continue to ask for the public's help for any information that might lead to an arrest. Anyone with information is urged to contact the Durham Police Department's homicide unit or CrimeStoppers at (919) 683-1200. The original investigator assigned to the case was E. Ortiz, who could be reached at (919) 560-4440, extension 29337.