Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
295 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Forum Posts for Paul Atchley:
Be respectful. Abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

I’ve been following the case of Paul Frederic Atchley and something that’s been on my mind is the timeline of events between his disappearance and the discovery of the blood-soaked items. It just seems so strange to me that Harold Ordway, the guy he was staying with, would end up in an accident with all that evidence left in his truck. It almost feels like he was trying to get caught or maybe he just didn’t think the police would put two and two together so quickly. I wonder if there’s any chance that someone else might have been involved, or if Ordway really did act alone as he claims. It's chilling to think about how calculated or careless this could have been.
I also read about the connection to Michael VanBuskirk, which seems to complicate things even more. Two disappearances linked to the same person in such a short span? It’s hard not to speculate about what was really going on in that house. If anyone has any theories or more information on what Ordway's motive might have been, I’d love to hear your thoughts. It’s so sad that Paul’s family hasn’t been able to find closure.
Wow, the details of Paul Atchley’s disappearance are truly unsettling. Has anyone else looked into the timeline of events? It's weird how things unfolded with Atchley going missing the day before Ordway’s car crash. I wonder what happened during that window of time. Also, with blood-soaked items found in the truck, it makes you think about what was going on in their living situation. I'm curious about the dynamics between Atchley, Ordway, and VanBuskirk — did anyone ever dig into their backgrounds or possible disputes? If anyone local to Delton or Plainwell has insights or heard anything around that time in 2011, would love to hear your thoughts!