Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
298 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Forum Posts for Jay Close:
Be respectful. Abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

I was reading through some old cases and came across the tragic story of Jay D. Close from Dundee, NY. One aspect that really got to me was the chaos on Union Street before the shooting. Can you imagine living in a small town like that, thinking you're safe, only to have a crazed individual firing a shotgun into your home? That must have been absolutely terrifying for the residents. It's just so sad the way things escalated. I can't help but feel for Close's family and the people of Dundee who had to endure such fear and then grapple with the loss of such a young man, especially on Christmas Eve. Cases like this really highlight the dangers law enforcement officers face, even when they're still learning the ropes.
I’ve been reading about Constable Jay D. Close and I can’t stop thinking about how incredibly young he was. Just 21, with a whole life ahead of him, stepping up to protect his community on what was literally his first day. It’s deeply unsettling to realize that he was thrown into such a dangerous situation right from the start. It’s hard to imagine what his family went through, losing someone so dear on Christmas Eve. I really feel for them, and for the residents of Dundee who had to experience such violence and loss in their tight-knit community. Jay’s story is a stark reminder of the unpredictability and risks faced by those in law enforcement, especially when mental health issues are involved. I hope the town found some healing over the years.
I've been digging into the Jay D. Close case, and something that really stands out to me is the role mental illness played in all of this. After the suspect was found to be "hopelessly insane" and transferred to Mattaewan, it begs the question: was he already dealing with severe mental health issues before the shooting, or did his actions and their consequences push him over the edge? It's a tragic situation all around, especially for Jay and his loved ones, who were deprived of seeing him live his life and career as a constable. The legal system's decision to classify the suspect as insane seems to hint at complexities in understanding mental health over a century ago. Has anyone else looked into how cases like this were typically handled back then? It makes me wonder what might have been different if this happened today, with our current mental health knowledge and resources.