Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
298 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Forum Posts for Janet Shirar:
Be respectful. Abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

I’ve been following Janet Shirar’s case for a while, and something that keeps coming back to my mind is the timeline around the birthday cake detail. I can’t help but think how this simple errand, buying a cake for her nephew, shows her commitment to family even in her busy life. That’s someone who truly cared for the people around her. It’s so troubling to think about how something so ordinary, a small cake for a party, was one of the last things she did.
I wonder if the cake purchase or planning tied Janet to any particular store or location that evening. Was it checked by investigators for potential footage or witnesses? Or was it ever confirmed whether she actually completed this errand or not? It might not lead directly to the killer, but any piece of the puzzle could be critical in a case that's had so few answers for so long. My heart goes out to her family and friends, who have been seeking justice and answers for over four decades. It must be incredibly frustrating to know there's a potential witness out there that hasn’t come forward or felt pressured to withhold information. I hope someday soon there’s a breakthrough in this case. We need to keep discussing this and bringing attention to Janet’s story.
I've been following Janet Shirar's case, and something I can't shake off is the peculiar way her crime scene was left. I mean, it's baffling how the crime was so brutal, yet there seemed to be such a deliberate arrangement of details afterward. The fact that her body was positioned with so much care—arms straight, palms cleaned—makes me wonder what message the killer was trying to send or if it was an act of guilt. It's almost as if they wanted Janet to maintain some dignity even in such tragic circumstances, which is just eerie to think about.
Also, her clothes being neatly stacked in the closet really throws me for a loop. It’s like the killer wanted to make sure nothing was out of place, which feels oddly personal and intimate. Does anyone have thoughts on what this could mean? It’s such a chilling contrast to the violence that took place, and it makes me think that whoever did this wasn't just some random intruder. It seems like someone she knew well, but what could drive such a horrific act? It’s just so painful thinking about what her family must have gone through and continues to endure without answers. Hoping for any breakthrough that could bring some closure. Any thoughts?
Reading about Janet Shirar's case has really struck a chord with me, especially when it comes to the discovery of the crime scene. It's unsettling to think that someone could rearrange a scene so deliberately, almost suggesting a twisted sense of familiarity or personal intent. The way Janet’s body was positioned so carefully, and her hands wiped clean, seems to indicate a level of control or perhaps even an attempt to remove something. It's haunting to imagine the calm amidst such violence.
What’s also puzzling is the missing timeline segment. The gap between midnight when Janet last spoke to her friend on the phone, and the 3:00am estimated murder time is troubling. Is it possible the killer was lurking nearby, waiting for a moment to strike, or was it someone who had been there all along? And then there’s the phone stand’s bizarre positioning, suggesting someone had used the phone or wanted it to appear a certain way. It’s amazing that after all these years, these seemingly small details haven't led to a break in the case.
Does anyone have insights on what it means when a crime scene is altered in such ways? Could it suggest certain psychological traits of an offender or possibly paint a picture of premeditated intentions? It’s deeply saddening for the family and everyone who knew Janet, to have answers lingering just out of reach.