Do you know who murdered James Dennis Boulware in 1987? Easter Sunday in 1987 brought a brutal and tragic end to the life of James Dennis Boulware, a 39-year-old African-American man from Shelby, North Carolina. Known to his friends and family, James was visiting Gastonia for the weekend, planning to stay at the home of his cousin. The holiday, a time of renewal and family gatherings, was shattered by an act of violence that has left a community with unanswered questions for decades. His death is one of several cold cases from that era that the Gastonia Police Department continues to investigate, hoping that someone will finally come forward with the information needed to close a painful chapter.
The morning of April 19, 1987, began with a grim discovery. At approximately 4:50 a.m., James's cousin, Oscar Sanders, and his girlfriend, Karen Bradshaw, returned to their residence at 936 Hallmark Drive in a west Gastonia neighborhood.
They had been out the previous night and were horrified to find James lying lifeless on the kitchen floor. He had been shot three times in the head in what police would later describe as a "cold-blooded execution." The last time anyone reported seeing James alive was around 11:30 p.m. the night before, when a friend saw him. In the hours between then and the discovery of his body, his life was violently taken.
Gastonia Police were called to the scene and immediately began a homicide investigation. The initial assessment pointed toward a robbery gone wrong, but with other potential motives. Investigators noted that James’s pants pockets had been turned inside out, suggesting his killer or killers had been looking for money or valuables. Adding another layer to the case, several small bags containing substances believed to be cocaine and marijuana were found at the scene. This led detectives to suspect the murder was connected to both robbery and drugs. Despite the apparent leads, no murder weapon was ever recovered from the home.
The killing sent a wave of shock through the quiet neighborhood, particularly as the news spread on Easter Sunday. One neighbor, Sara Nelson, speaking to The Gaston Gazette at the time, expressed the community's dismay, stating, "It's just a shame something like this has to happen, especially on Easter." The violent nature of the crime, an execution-style shooting inside a private home, left residents unsettled and searching for answers alongside the police. Then-Maj. Dennis Crosby of the Gastonia Police Department underscored the brutality of the act, calling it a "cold-blooded execution."
In the years and decades that have followed, the investigation into the murder of James Dennis Boulware has remained open but unsolved. The Gastonia Police Department has kept his file active, alongside more than a dozen other homicides from that period that have grown cold. Detectives have revisited the evidence, but without new information or witnesses, the trail has remained elusive. No suspects have ever been publicly named or charged in connection with the crime. The case represents one of twenty unsolved city homicides over five years old that the department was still seeking answers for as of 2016.
The family and friends of James Boulware have been left to navigate a future without him, burdened by the lack of justice or closure. The passage of time has not diminished the hope that someone, somewhere, holds the key to understanding what happened in that kitchen on Hallmark Drive. As of September 2016, the case was still being highlighted by local media in an effort to generate new leads. The Gastonia Police Department continues to ask that anyone with information, no matter how insignificant it may seem, come forward. The memory of James Boulware and the violent end to his life await the finality that only justice can provide.